Personal and Contextual Drivers of Collective Engagement in Facial Difference Groups
Experiences of stigma and discrimination are often understood in terms of their effects on individual psychological well-being. Yet the ways people respond to these experiences are also shaped by relationships, social identities, and opportunities for connection. For individuals with facial differences, communities organized around shared experiences may provide opportunities for mutual understanding, belonging, and collective responses to stigma. Access to these communities, however, is not equally available to everyone.
In the MRI-funded project Personal and Contextual Drivers of Collective Engagement in Facial Difference Groups, Marisa Krauter (Oregon State University) examines how adults with facial differences discover, participate in, or disengage from communities organized around shared experiences. The project investigates how personal identities, social environments, and structural inequalities shape opportunities for collective engagement and whether brief interventions can increase awareness of and interest in community participation.
The term facial difference refers to facial appearances that differ from commonly held expectations. These differences may result from congenital conditions, medical diagnoses, injuries, scarring, facial paralysis, or other circumstances. Although individual experiences vary, people with facial differences may encounter unwanted attention, negative assumptions, discrimination, and barriers to social participation.
Much of the existing research has focused on the psychological consequences of these experiences and the individual strategies people use to manage stigma. Krauter's project extends this perspective by examining collective coping: the ways individuals may draw on shared identities, interpersonal relationships, and community participation to navigate challenges that arise within broader social environments.
Organizations such as Changing Faces, myFace, and FaceOut provide opportunities for individuals with facial differences to exchange experiences, access resources, and participate in advocacy. Such communities may offer forms of understanding and support that are difficult to obtain elsewhere. However, some individuals may be unaware that these organizations exist, may not identify with the term facial difference, or may encounter barriers that limit their participation.
The project also considers how experiences of racism, sexism, ableism, and other forms of discrimination intersect with facial difference-related stigma. These broader social conditions may influence whether individuals feel represented within existing organizations, perceive them as welcoming, or have the resources and opportunities needed to participate.
Drawing on social identity theory, the research examines how identification with a group may contribute to belonging, shared meaning, and collective responses to discrimination. Rather than treating coping solely as an individual psychological process, this framework situates adaptation within relationships and social systems. It also recognizes that the value and meaning of community involvement may differ across individuals and contexts.
The MRI-funded project consists of two complementary studies.
The first uses qualitative interviews with approximately 15 adults who self-identify as having a facial difference. Participants will discuss how they became aware of facial difference communities, what motivated or discouraged their participation, and how their experiences of identity, stigma, and social support have influenced their decisions about engagement.
The interviews will also examine experiences of disengagement. Community participation may provide meaningful support, but individuals may choose to reduce their involvement or leave organizations for reasons related to accessibility, representation, interpersonal experiences, or changing personal needs. Understanding these processes may help clarify the conditions under which community relationships become supportive, challenging, or less relevant over time.
Findings from the qualitative study will inform a second, experimental pilot study involving approximately 60 adults with facial differences. Participants will be randomly assigned to one of three conditions: viewing a brief video featuring an individual discussing their experiences of community involvement, reading a written account of the same experiences, or receiving neutral educational information about craniofacial conditions.
The intervention is based on the possibility that indirect exposure to another person's experiences may increase awareness of available communities and create opportunities for identification and connection. For individuals who have had limited contact with facial difference organizations, these materials may provide an accessible introduction to collective support without requiring immediate participation.
The researchers will assess the acceptability, appropriateness, and feasibility of these brief interventions, alongside preliminary measures of community engagement, collective identity, and psychosocial well-being. Assessments will take place before and immediately after the intervention, with follow-up extending to three months.
As a pilot study, the primary objective is to determine whether these approaches are practical and acceptable and to generate preliminary evidence that can inform larger investigations. The project is not designed to establish definitive intervention effectiveness.
The findings may have implications for healthcare providers and community organizations seeking to improve access to peer support. Healthcare settings, for example, may offer opportunities to introduce individuals and families to community resources, while organizations themselves may benefit from a better understanding of the factors that encourage participation or contribute to disengagement.
Importantly, the project does not assume that community involvement is necessary or beneficial for every individual with a facial difference. Instead, it examines how opportunities for connection can become more accessible and responsive to different identities, experiences, and preferences.
By investigating the relationships among stigma, social identity, and collective engagement, this MRI-funded project contributes to a systemic understanding of coping and resilience. It recognizes that responses to discrimination develop not only through individual adaptation but also through interactions with communities and social institutions. Understanding these processes may help clarify when and how shared experiences become resources for connection, belonging, and collective support.